Took me a while, but I found it

Apparently, the only company currently manufacturing a small MP3 player that also doubles as an AM/FM radio is PoGo! Electronics.

http://www.pogoelectronics.com/radioyourway.html

The price is a little steep, but it doubles as a recorder with timer presets. I can just see myself listening to CarTalk without having to get up at 10am on the weekends.