Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by carlylegee - 11/16/03 4:25 PM
Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? And if they do work, how do I know if it is real or fake?
by: carlylegee November 16, 2003 4:25 PM PST
0 people like this thread
Staff pick
Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by carlylegee - 11/16/03 4:25 PM
Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? And if they do work, how do I know if it is real or fake?
Total posts: 57 (Showing page 1 of 2)
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by R. Proffitt
- 11/16/03 4:48 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Work in what way?
a. Boosting money from your pocket.
b. Boosting the seller's sales.
c. Boosting the maker's coffers.
In short, all of the above.
Bob
Staff pick
Placebo - they may help your perception, but not your signal
by wirelessdr - 1/5/06 10:16 AM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by R. Proffitt
Fact: Sugar pills given as placebos have helped some people with every illness tested. Should we all take sugar pills, just in case? Placing the metal sticker behind the battery would be like putting the sugar pill in your pocket!
Hold your phone still for 3-5 minutes - the signal will fluctuate.
Now move the phone 6 inches, wait 10-20 seconds for your meter to update - the signal will fluctuate.
Now rotate your phone and wait 20 sec - fluctuates.
Fact: wireless signals are constantly changing strength and they vary with location. An increase of 1 bar is typically 4 to 10 times more signal.
Staff pick
cell phone antenna boosters
by qsally - 8/10/09 1:38 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by R. Proffitt
Goodness, what a bunch of miss-information. How do you think you can use your phone in a mall?
Cell phone signals are just radio frequency signals,and have been around since 1865 in England, closer to 1900 in the states. In both cases they started building boosters about 5 minutes later.
All of the dishes and dishes you see on commercial buildings are transmitting and receiving radio frequency signals being pushed by amplifiers (boosters).
And the service providers do sell them - and have them installed for their large user customers in fooice buildings. Additionally Verizon uses Wilson Electronics boosters (repeater systems) in their National Communications Center that they bought from UnwiredSignal.com. I know because I engineered it and talked with them by phone after they installed it.
I have also engineered and sold Wilson systems to the US Homeland Security,US Army, Navy, Marines, Chevron Dow and our company has sold thousands to individuals for their homes, offices, cars and cabins.
Those decals the go inside the phone don't work and can't. It is against FCC regulations to boost the signal at the point of the head. Besides, what did you think you were getting for a dollar?
forums are great. I love them. Then I come across people who are talking when they should be listening.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by JordanBisasky - 11/21/03 3:07 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I have a hunch that if they do work, it's an insignificant difference.
Note that if you are not getting signals altogether, I doubt it will provide any help at all. Since that simply means you are not located near a tower.
Staff pick
Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by brenline - 2/1/04 11:53 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by JordanBisasky
I have tried them is several phones and found no improvement at all .I think they are a usless gimmick
Staff pick
Re:Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by bergyis1 - 4/7/04 4:33 PM
In Reply to: Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by brenline
I'm told they only work with analog phones. Absolutely useless with any digital mode - Dawn in New Hampshire
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Unknown - 2/3/04 12:33 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Yes i purchased same, time ago, and installedit and it improved the coverage, yes, Javier
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by limeyprat - 2/27/04 10:57 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Some times it's best to ask yourself, "What colour are the emperors new clothes"?
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by jwahlund - 3/14/04 8:28 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
No!!! They don't work.
Staff pick
Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by glockgemini - 4/5/04 7:26 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by jwahlund
I still have one in my Nokia 390 and I got a marginal improvement in a semi-dead area. Probably about 25% boost. It did allow me to have longer converstations without any disconnects.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by gemcquaid - 3/30/04 1:59 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I have 2 different types of Antenna Boosters, the one that tapes to your phone, & another that is like a regular antenna for placing outside your window, with a wire that leads back to the phone. I really don't think either boosts reception any. I am good at wasting money on gagets that have fabulous claims, but when you get them, they don't work any better then nothing at all. So, my answer would be; No they don't work.
Eugene L. McQuaid
mcquaid@northlink.com
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Skip376 - 4/4/04 8:16 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I haven't found any antenna boosters which really work on the regular market. I suggest contact your service provider and see about upgrading your phone or get a new service provider.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Firefly21645 - 4/4/04 8:21 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Yes, they do. I live in the Texas Hill Country. Getting cell phone reception when you're between hills can be a real problem here. Since I put an antenna in my cell phone, it doesn't cut out any more when I'm trying to talk on my phone while going through the hills. As for whether it's a legitimate antenna or not, I'd suggest buying it at a reputable store, rather than at a flea market or through an ad.
Staff pick
Putting a ant on is not a booster.
by Marv99 - 6/1/05 11:07 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by Firefly21645
Putting a higher ant on anything can help. This is not a booster. It's an ant. Since cell freaks are basically line of sight hight is better. Less blocks higher. Also some antennas have hight gain than others. But that's a factor of the ant.
So yeah that should help.
BTW hi neighbor. <G>
Close to Buda
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by drbigric - 4/4/04 11:02 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
NO!!!!!
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by zimpsygrp - 4/5/04 12:38 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Q) Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
A) My experience has been that they do work, but with a caveat! I've noticed that with the antenna, I am able to get signal in certain areas where I had none without the antenna. The problem is that I now get no signal in some areas that I did have signal before!
Q) ...if they do work, how do I know if it is real or fake?
A) If it works for you, then I guess it works! I'm not sure if the antenna funtions as a signal booster, however, or just a more directional antenna than the one built into the phone.
Staff pick
do cell phone antennas work?
by qsally - 8/10/09 1:34 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by zimpsygrp
Goodness, what a bunch of miss-information. How do you think you can use your phone in a mall? Why do police cars use multiple antennas (for different devices) on their cars?
Cell phone signals are just radio frequency signals that have been around since 1865 in England, closer to 1900 in the states. In both cases they started building boosters about 5 minutes later.
All of the antennas and dishes you see on commercial buildings are transmitting and receiving radio frequency signals that are being pushed by amplifiers (boosters).
Quality wireless cell phone signal boosters (repeaters) just do the same thing cell phone towers do (those little houses by the cell phone towers house powerful amplifiers and huge battery packs). That is to push a signal that's here to the tower (repeater) over there, that continues down the line.
And the service providers do sell them - and have them installed for their large user customers in office and other commercial buildings.
Verizon uses a Wilson Electronics booster (wireless repeater system) in their National Communications Center that they bought from UnwiredSignal.com. I know because I engineered it and talked with them by phone after they installed it.
I have also engineered and sold Wilson systems to US Homeland Security,US Army, Navy, Marines, Chevron, Dow and many other big orgianzitions and UnwiredSignal has sold thousands over the years to individuals for their homes, offices, cars and cabins.
Those decals that go inside the phone don't work and can't. It is against FCC regulations to boost the signal at the point of the head. Besides, what did you think you were getting for a dollar?
Forums are great. I love them. Then I come across people who are yacking when they should be listening.
If anyone needs further information about cell phone signal boosters, I can be reached through the company mentioned above. The 800 number is at the top of every one of the thousand pages. I'm usually a nice guy.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Keithj - 4/5/04 1:30 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
Simply, no. They don't amplify the signal in any way.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by drp - 4/5/04 3:59 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I installed one and it DID NOT work. My signal was worse after i installed it. It was a total wast of money.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by billsailer - 4/5/04 5:33 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I have cell phone antenna boosters in two phones, and am pleased that they help extend my reception into areas that were more limited.
The ones I have, that self attach onto the inside body
of the phone do help.
I am in an area on the Eastern Shore of Maryland that has a lot of dead spots around Crisfield,Deal Island and Oriole, and areas along Route 13 going to Salisbury, Maryland.
They reduce the size of the dead spots, and make the calls that I make near them clearer. They are a help where the spacing of the towers is further apart. In a city I don't notice any difference. Been using them 8 years or so. My own house is a dead spot that nothing helps, I go one block away, and get fine reception.
Staff pick
Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by hokienet - 4/5/04 6:28 AM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by billsailer
They work for me, been using them for several years. I live in the mountains of SW Virginia and my phones work better then those that don't have it when down in the valleys.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by bperrin - 4/5/04 6:00 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
I received one as a gift. I had two identical phones with the same provider and so I installed it in one phone and used the other as an unaltered comparison. I actually found some small improvement on the phone with the antenna (a small sheet of plastic with a circuit traced on it) but the results were unpredictable. To assure myself that it wasn't the phone, I then switched the antenna to the other phone and found that the improvement moved with the antenna. Would I recommend the antenna? With some qualification. First the price should be low, not twenty five or even twenty dollars, more on the order of ten dollars or less. Second, it seems to be most useful in fringe areas where service fades in and out. It does not seem to help measurably in areas with reasonable singnal strength. I have since purchased a new phone and moved the antenna to the new phone. Then another phone and moved the antenna again. In each case, I found a small but measurable difference with the antenna. My provider is T-Mobile and I also moved the chip back and forth for further assurance.
Staff pick
Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Swine flu - 4/5/04 6:23 AM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by bperrin
Speaking as a repair technician for a major cellphone manufacturer, I can tell you now that NO, they do not work. The little cicuit looking ones they tell you to place between your battery and the housing are a rip off.
There are a few things you can do to get better reception. Some aftermarket antennas have a lower resistance than the one from the manufacturer and will cause lower signals to be slightly heightened, but they also reduce quality of transmissions.
The Intenna, antenna ampplifyer and others that are a paste on or stick on are simply only making them money by boosting the consumer.
Staff pick
Re:Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by inorga - 4/13/04 10:42 PM
In Reply to: Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by Swine flu
I've heard the same from others, and I've worked in cellular retail sale for a long time. I've tried a couple of the little sticker ones, and the more pricey (and more professionally packaged) ones actually made reception on my own phone go from fading in and out of maybe a half-bar of reception (cutting in and out) to two full bars in my friend's basement.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by Cellphonetech - 4/5/04 6:19 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
If they did work, don't you think the service providers stores would stock them?
They don't work!
Staff pick
Re:Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by tboy - 5/21/04 12:00 PM
In Reply to: Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by Cellphonetech
"If they did work, don't you think the service providers stores would stock them?"
No. Because that would be addmiting they are selling faulty products.
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by mah56j - 4/5/04 6:38 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
The little stick-on type don't seem to do anything. But I did discover a partial solution when using my cell phone in my office( where the signal is very weak). The C. Craine Company sells an aentenna for use in trucks to boost cell phone signal--http://www.ccrane.com/cellular_antenna.asp It definitely works. Drawbacks--it costs $75, plugs into the charging socket on your cell phone, and in my case I drilled a hole in my office wall and hung the device from a shrub. If you want to get a few looks, walk down the street with it ![]()
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by gkloc - 4/5/04 10:13 AM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
You ask a valid question, but forget one very important fact. You cannot get something for nothing. There is/are no amplifiers circuits and it draws no current (electricity), thus it gives you exactly what it gets - nothing. Nuf said.....
Staff pick
Re:Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work?
by legesdiamonds - 4/5/04 3:23 PM
In Reply to: Does anyone know if the Antenna Boosters work? by carlylegee
NOT NO: BUT HELL NO. i am not an/a electronic engineer, but it seems to reason that if you remove your battery and stick the booster to the phone and reinstall the battery, you have just set up a magnetic field which will produce interference. yes i have tried these and they do not work. save your money.
Staff pick
Total posts: 57 (Showing page 1 of 2)
Moderator
CNET Staff
Samsung Staff
Dell StaffYou are e-mailing the following post: Post Subject
You are reporting the following post: Post Subject
You are posting a reply to: Post Subject
Thank you, , your post has been submitted.
> Click here to view your post. > Manage your tracked discussions. > Track this discussion. CloseThank you, , your post has been submitted and will appear on our site shortly.
Close
