Forum feedback forum: Do you trust CNET?

I trust Cnet for the most part, but acknowledge that, like with all companies, there will be lapses. Every so often a malware-infected program will make its way onto download.com, a post be wrongfully deleted, or a review overlook some aspect of the product. In addition, each individual has his/her own set of criteria and personal interests, which affect the focus and overall score to a certain degree. That's why I always look at the information and make my own judgment instead of simply relying on what others tell me. However, I don't consider Cnet to be any less accurate or forthright than Consumer Reports or those grading the nation's SATs. They are a valuable resource, one which I have come to utilize more often.

As to the rest:
* Yes, Cnet receives a good portion of its revenue from advertising, and these forums would not be here without it. However, I've never seen a review, recommendation, etc. given or skewed as a result of advertising agreements.
* Yes, I suppose it did make it onto the boards. That or I'm dreaming.
* I doubt many will reply given the limited traffic in this forum.

On a side note, Consumer Reports charges for most of their information and advertises their own publications. Ever wonder if they've over-hyped their subscriptions to make a little extra revenue? Ever chosen products to catch the reader's attention and not just be fair and equal with their product selections? Ever withheld critical information in an effort to get you to buy a subscription? I don't know, but while you're on the subject...

John

When I was in the market for a digital camera, a community member recommended one. So I checked the CNet review, and Consumer Reports, both of which rated it well. I bought the camera, and have been pleased with it.

I refer to Consumer Reports before buying a lot of stuff. However, they recently admitted an error in reviewing (I think a child car seat). But they quickly admitted their mistake. That builds trust for me.

I see in the forums that members are also quick to point out "bad advice". And I have seen them complain about some offerings from Downloads. So there are many "team members" here.

The same question could be asked about help-oriented services, such as tech support for the electronics we buy, from TVs to computers. The same for auto mechanics, delivery services, and even our health care providers. IMO, when push comes to shove, it behooves us all to educate ourselves as best we can in order to make the best judgements we can.

That being said, I admit that I have made my share of errors in judgement, so I can't always trust myself.

Thank you for your nice comments about our community!

Angeline

Thanks to all who replied. Good answers.

John's response gave me a flashback. As a newbie nearly a decade ago my absolute favorite television show was "Call For Help." Leo Laporte was, what the call these days, THE BOMB!

Thanks for the memories.

(For those unacquainted with Leo you can visit him at leoville.com.)