Networking & wireless forum: Comcast and wireless routers

I appreciate your input very much, but I was looking for something I could just run to Circuit City or Wal-Mart and grab... If someone could just take a look at these links and give me a suggestion I would be very greatful.

Thank You..

http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Networking/sem/rpsm/catOid/-12980/N/20012961+20012980+5102/link/ref/rpem/ccd/categorylist.do

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=4722179

Again, Thank You for any help...

hopefully i can provide a little more insight than a link and an explanation of the link.................

if all you want is interet access for your laptops, well then you could go with a wireless B (11mbps) router which is still probably way faster than your internet connection, but they sell those widely anymore, so you should get a wireless G.

however if you, likemyself tend to send files across your network (especially larger ones) then you may want wireless G (54mbps) definitely or a draft n (100-300mbps) router.

for example, i just got a D-Link DSM-510 network media player. so now i've gotten into "streaming video." i NEEEEED all the speed and extra bandwidth i can get. so i want a Wireless N router with a Gigabit swich. but then i maaaay be a bit on the advanced end of the spectrum.

in theory... its all "easy to setup." in practice, i have purched linksys routers (wireless b, g and soon an n), and they seem to work... pretty good with limitations.

main limitation. I dont know of ANY brand or standard (a,b,g,n... mimo or otherwise) that can reach 200 feet.... the wireless N routers or routers with MIMO are supposed to have the best range. but Cnet's tests say they get reeally slow at around the 160' mark. take into account walls, microwave, cordless phones, whatever gear your neighbors have... that figure can fall rapidly further...

what i've found. none of this stuff works ALL the time, sometimes i have to unplug-plugin my router to reset it and evrything gets going again. i live in a roughly 2000+ sq ft house. most of the time it says i have "very good" to "excellent" coverage anywhere in the house. but sometimes it conks out.

im looking into upgrading soon from a Linksys WRT54G to a Linksys WRT350N for the extended range/speed. its a bit expensive but hopefully worth it.

AS FOR A RECOMMENDATION.

you sound like you want something realllly simple.

D-Link's "Rangebooster G Wireless Router"
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/D-Link-Rangebooster-G-Wireless-Router-WBR2310/sem/rpsm/oid/147500/catOid/-12980/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do
seems to be a good deal at circuit city.

unless you prefer to "walk in, walk out" of a brick and mortar store with your purchase... i ALWAYS look at Amazon.com first... usually no tax, free shipping. and if that isnt enough, usually their prices are actually better than CC and best buy (even befooore the no tax/free shipping!!!) and they are a reputable store.

the router im looking at is 163.99 on amazon, no tax free shipping. its 179.99 at circuit city plus tax, and i actually have to drive to the store and deal with the pimply-faced teenagers they call store-reps to get it..... no brainer for me.

Thank you for your input and help. It sems that people have a lot of trouble with wireless routers, on the CC website there are some very good and some very bad reviews for each one. So I guess I will just buy the one I can get the best deal on and hope for the best...

Thank You.

Especially with the basic entry-level home routers, as what you pay for is usually what you get. At the bottom of the price ladder are usually the DLinks, which work well for the most part, but are notorious for stability problems, causing them to burp and need to be reset from time to time. This might seem trivial at first, but gets very annoying very fast, as when it happens, it also knocks all your computers offline.

At the other end of the spectrum are the Linksys routers, which, for the most part work very well and have good stability. However, Linksys routers also usually carry the highest price tags between all routers with similar feature sets.

I guess at the end of the day, you just have to decide how much you want to spend.

The only other thing that I wanted to mention is that wireless networks are sometimes prone to interference (which usually, in effect will randomly knock your computer offline), most commonly from 2.4GHz cordless phones present in the same airspace as the wireless network. While it might not be fatal to the computer wireless network, if yo do have problems with it, you might want to upgrade the cordless phones to 5.8GHz.