Is a hybrid drive needed to be defragged?
by Magic-wand - 4/22/12 6:42 PM
Will it harm the drive since it consists with a SSD?
Attention forum users: We want you to try out the new CNET forums platform! Click here to read the details. Thanks!
by: Magic-wand April 22, 2012 6:42 PM PDT
0 people like this thread
Total posts: 9 (Showing page 1 of 1)
It has no need, but
This need appears to be one of the owner and not the device.
One of the signs of a new computer "tech" is they defrag the machine. As they get more seasoned, they stop doing that.
Some reports say, defragment is not necessary for modern hd
Is it true?
We have the hardware and we have the user.
by R. Proffitt - 4/30/12 12:21 PM
Which one are you trying to convince? I find the users are the ones that want to discuss defragmenting until they get upset about it.
And the OS in use can matter, but at the end of the day you make your choice and use the machine.
Then again, my neighbor seems to use the machine solely to defragment. That is, it's the only thing I've ever seen it running.
I just read the related article in a magazine
I just read the article about this on a computer magazine.
Is it violate the forums rules if I indicate the magazine name?(I am not going or trying to promote any magazine here.)
I bought a hybrid drive and a WD Raptor, both for Windows system, few days ago. I just wanted to know if these kinds of hard drives needed to be defragged in Windows environment?
Should be fine.
There is a lot of outdated information out there. Like "hiding the WiFi SSID." That is not adding much security if any but has been found to cause problems for many. How would we update all the old advice?
And about your question. It's a good one but since the hybrid area of flash does not benefit from defragmenting and how it works has little to do with the HDD contents it's going to come down to what the user feels is best. OR you clone the drive, and test it on the defragged clone and the fragged clone to verify it made any difference.
Here with 8GB RAM, the hybrid drive (I put one in my laptop!) I haven't defragged since I installed the new HDD and my machine boots from the really neat zero power sleep system in under 5 seconds. Why defrag?
You can defrag a hybrid drive, but you shouldn't
I have a regular SSD, but I read about the hybrid drives when planning my PC build. From what I read, if you defrag a hybrid drive, you will lose the benefit of the SSD part of the drive for a while. Files you use frequently are cached on the faster SSD part of the drive. When you defrag the drive, files are moved around on the disk. It will have to re-learn which files you use frequently and rebuild the cache on the SSD drive. I don't know how long this re-learning takes, if it's hours or days.
For what it's worth, this webpage from Seagate says to turn off the automatic defragging.
It doesn't matter if only lose the cache function for a whil
It doesn't matter if only lose the cache function for a while but it becomes a big problem if the SSD cache is defragged along with the disk since the frequently used data is stored in it.
When a drive is defragged, the data inside will be frequently used(move from one area to another). In this situation, will the frequently used data be mapped into SSD cache? It is my question in the very beginning.
Only the drive maker can answer but
by R. Proffitt - 5/5/12 12:59 PM
That is exactly what the hybrid drive is supposed to do. LEARN what is being used a lot and move that to the cache.
THERE is some debate if it really works so I can't answer if it really works or not. I own a few and yes they are faster but defragging today seems to be more for the user than the PC.
Total posts: 9 (Showing page 1 of 1)
You are posting a reply to: Post Subject
You are requesting a clarification of the question: Post Subject
You are posting an answer to the question: Post Subject
Would you like to resolve this question? close