Best video file format?
by RobberTom - 8/15/06 7:40 PM
What's the best video file format?
Attention forum users: We want you to try out the new CNET forums platform! Click here to read the details. Thanks!
by: RobberTom August 15, 2006 7:40 PM PDT
0 people like this thread
Total posts: 14 (Showing page 1 of 1)
(NT) (NT) DV if it's an SD camera.
There are no best, but...
if you tell us what your objectives are then maybe we can suggest what format to use.
You have to answer that.
Since a movie producer may have to stay in raw DV till the very end while someone with storage issues will want high compression.
One's best is the other's worst.
video format list
I need a spreadsheet listing all the currently available video formats for camcorders with columns next to the list showing pluses and minues for each format. Is there such a spreadsheet in any book or forum?
I am looking to buy a new camcorder because I am dissatisfied with the video quality of our present Sony mini DVD camcorder using MPEG-2 format. I am also dissatisfied with Sony Vegas Platinum editing software because they can't seem to make clear what video formats their software actually works with. So I may want to buy new editing software also.
Sadly, the number of CODECs grow daily it seems.
There are web sites about this but you can google that. What I want to share is how I deal with it. Here it is.
1. VirtualDub for transcoding.
2. VLC PLAYER is used sometimes.
3. "GSpot Codec Information Appliance" - "GSpot is a free utility which identifies the codec required to play an AVI file and supplies other information as well."
4. Google to find the codec and how to handle that oddly encoded file.
Let me end with this statement. I've encountered people that think that Sony or other software makers should handle this mess. Like someone told me -> "Never going to happen."
My son is dealing with this now as he enters his 3rd year of college during some courses but while the other students are stumped he's been able to move past the ideas the software is buggy and learn the tools to get the video imported and on the board.
Be afraid of what you ask for
Thank you for suggesting GSpot. I downloaded it and maybe I can translate some clips with it. But I opened the file listing all the codecs (audio and video formats?) and was overwhelmed. 99% of the info is beyond my understanding.
I just need to know what hard drive or flash drive camcorder will give me a good picture in medium inside lighting (MPEG-2 mini DVDs and Vegas don't) and what editing software will allow me to edit and label the clips taken.
Just buy, experiment, and return the camcorders that can't handle less than perfect lighting I guess. And use Gspot to translate clips into something Sony Vegas Platinum will understand. I have waded through and fought off several of the damn features to learn how to use this software for the basics.
"less than perfect lighting" =
You guessed it, less than perfect results. If you take any photo or other course work, guess what area they spend a lot of time on.
Let me be blunt here and that to cure bad lighting with better cameras is going to be very expensive. You will have to jump to the 5000+ pro cameras that are dead gimmes since you see the huge lens needed to get enough light. Small lens like your consumer products will need good lighting.
best video file format for the Big Screen
Hoping my video will be projected in movie theatres.
It's HD and 16.9 format.
Question: for very best quality projection in a theatre, what is the recommended file format? Mpg2?
Best would be no compression. Or lossless.
MPEG 2 would create artifacts that on such a big screen would have folk distracted from your work.
Stick to raw DV and test the result in a few encodings but so far, MPEG 2 is best for DVD home output and not much else.
Your advice is appreciated--and so quickly. I'll get to work researching how my low-end editing program relates to raw DV.
Sorry I was too quick to write "raw DV."
The topic is an old one and you need to translate my "raw DV" to something a little more what other folk can relate to. Here's the long explainer.
What we want is the lightest weight compressor or none OR one that does not introduce ARTIFACTS. MPEG in many versions does this -> (see) http://www.videohelp.com/forum/archive/best-quality-method-to-convert-dvd-to-avi-t299956.html
See the mpeg block artifacts?
You want to avoid this and if you are going big screen these are only going to get worse in almost any compression. So when I write "raw DV" I mean which ever format that does not compress so we don't get the artifacts and fuzz out as we load and save our work.
best video file for archiveing
i want to archive my old video files (video ts, vob)to external hard drive whats the best to convert them to for good quality file for future use
The good news is
That's been discussed. The answer was to NEVER convert content since with each conversion you encounter more loss.
-> Leave the files as-is and don't convert them.
Total posts: 14 (Showing page 1 of 1)