Version: 2008
  • On MovieTome: See the villain of IRON MAN 2!
Advanced Search
advertisement
advertisement
mySimon mySimon mySimon Outdoor Gear mySimon Swimwear mySimon Home and Garden

Forum display:

Peripherals: Where can I find a 4:3 monitor?

by zammer8 - 10/23/09 9:02 PM
advertisement
Post 1 of 15

Where can I find a 4:3 monitor?

by zammer8 - 10/23/09 9:02 PM

My 19" monitor has become too small for aging eyes. I would like a 21", perhaps 23." All I see for sale are wide-screen monitors. I don't watch movies on a monitor, run spreadsheets or have any use for the wide-screen format. My primary use is reading text, emails, viewing 4:3 format photos. When the WS show in 4:3 format, with bars on either side, the picture is smaller than 21", and I'd have too large a monitor body. I see in the desired format only quite expensive "pro" monitors for specialized users. Can you offer any suggestions?

Discussion locked
Post 2 of 15

Here's one...but

by ahtoi - 10/24/09 1:17 AM In reply to: Where can I find a 4:3 monitor? by zammer8

http://www.mwave.com/mwave/skusearch_v3.asp?scriteria=4131055

at $850, I think a better deal might be an HDTV. I have seen 32" for around 400-500.

Discussion locked
Post 3 of 15

Where can I find a 4:3 monitor.

by zammer8 - 10/24/09 1:30 AM In reply to: Here's one...but by ahtoi

It's out of my price class. WS monitors, 23", are going for 1/3 that. The problem is finding a reasonable 4:3. HDTV is not the way I want to go, nor that large. Thank you for replying.

Discussion locked
Post 4 of 15

See my use?

by R. Proffitt Moderator - 10/26/09 7:25 AM In reply to: Where can I find a 4:3 monitor? by zammer8

Here's my widescreen in play -> http://s175.photobucket.com/albums/w146/rproffitt2000/?action=view&current=desktop2.jpg

Works great.

Discussion locked
Post 5 of 15

How can I find a 4:3 monitor

by zammer8 - 10/29/09 4:00 PM In reply to: See my use? by R. Proffitt Moderator

Interesting. Thank you for showing it. However, it doesn't solve my goal of seeing a 21" 4:3 picture.

Discussion locked
Post 6 of 15

Remember there are few to none NEW units.

by R. Proffitt Moderator - 10/29/09 6:23 PM In reply to: How can I find a 4:3 monitor by zammer8

You'll have to hit the used market like http://www.amazon.com/DELL-1905FP-UltraSharp-19-inch-Adjustable/dp/B001312BV6

Sorry, but this does not meet your 21 inch goal. Just an example where you have to get something used.
Bob

Discussion locked
Post 7 of 15

Where can I find a 4:3 monitor

by zammer8 - 10/29/09 7:53 PM In reply to: Remember there are few to none NEW units. by R. Proffitt Moderator

Thanks for the suggestion. I regularly check Amazon. I hoped to find that a company was still making a 4:3 for the consumer market. I suppose they all get their glass from a few manufactureres, who decided everyone wants to watch movies on their monitors. It may be just my aquaintances, but no one I know watches movies on monitors.

Discussion locked
Post 8 of 15

If

by samkh - 10/30/09 6:44 AM In reply to: Where can I find a 4:3 monitor by zammer8

19" is too small, 21" isn't going to help. Besides, practically all popular makes of 4:3 are only up to 20". AND a usually higher native res of bigger models won't help your eyes!

Are you limited by a hutch dimension or something that forbids widescreen? Why don't you pick a larger font for emails and other text uses.

Discussion locked
Post 9 of 15

4:e monitor

by zammer8 - 10/30/09 11:06 AM In reply to: If by samkh

Fonts can be made only so large until the page no longer fits the screen. I could fit a WS on my desk, but have no use for a WS and have better use for the room. Your point about native resolution doesn't appear to hold up in practioe; A friend's 22" 4:3 does show everything fine for me. Unfortunately, he won't sell it.
I appreciate the advice posters have offered, and thank them, it helped. I see no need to keep this discussion open any longer.

Discussion locked
Post 10 of 15

4:3

by jean harrington - 10/30/09 5:52 PM In reply to: 4:e monitor by zammer8

Why don't you lower your resolution?

Discussion locked
Post 11 of 15

4:3 monitor

by zammer8 - 10/30/09 6:47 PM In reply to: 4:3 by jean harrington

By mentioning only text, I wasn't clear that I want everything larger, photos, maps. I just want a larger monitor, as people do a larger TV. Again, thanks, but I'm closing the post after the next reply.

Discussion locked
Post 12 of 15

I understand

by john3347 - 10/30/09 6:22 PM In reply to: Where can I find a 4:3 monitor? by zammer8

I get so frustrated with the people who have the attitude that if you don't want what they want, you want the wrong thing. I, personally, absolutely do not understand why computer monitors, or even TVs for that matter, have adopted the panoramic movie aspect ratio. I certainly understand your need for a larger monitor with a reasonable 4/3 aspect ratio. I refuse to buy the popular 16/9 and 16/10 computer monitors. After all the number of toolbars and ridiculously high toolbars (Office 2007 & 2010 Ribbon is perhaps the most conspicuous offender) are laid out across the screen, you have no screen left.

Now to your question. I have not done this, but have considered it. If your space and location permits why do you not just use a 21" to 25" CRT TV as a monitor. To my knowledge there are no current LCD monitors larger than 19" available in a 4/3 ratio and no LCD non-widescreen TVs currently on the market in any size. I recently found - and bought - an HP L1910 19" LCD monitor which, curiously, has a 5/4 aspect ratio. (slightly taller than 4/3) Love it!

Discussion locked
Post 13 of 15

4:e monitor

by zammer8 - 10/30/09 7:04 PM In reply to: I understand by john3347

They did it for marketing reasons. The trend is to watch movies online or DVD on a large monitor, and by far most movies are released in wide screen, so the belief is people want WS monitors, or will. It's the same with large-screen TVs; they're virtually all WS, with different zooms. TV programers have adapted to fit the screens.
For those with niche needs for largeer 4:3 monitors, they're available, but expensive, because the demand is low, and the typical users need top quality. CRTs, according to Consumer Reports, still have the best pictures, but it's a step backwards I'm not willing to go. I'll keep an eye on the used market, and for the odd larger 4:3 that, like the grail, is out there somewhere. Thanks for your thoughts, with which I'm in total agreement, but the bottom line rules.

Discussion locked
Post 14 of 15

Have you considered portrait mode?

by grichardt - 11/1/09 8:08 PM In reply to: 4:e monitor by zammer8

Have you considered purchasing a 23-24 inch flat panel and turning it on its side while using portrait mode? This might give you the display you desire at a reasonable price.

Discussion locked
Post 15 of 15

4:3 monitor

by zammer8 - 11/1/09 9:08 PM In reply to: Have you considered portrait mode? by grichardt

Thank you. It's been suggested, above, and doesn't provide a 21" 4:3 picture, which is what I seek.
PLEASE NOTE: THE THREAD IS CLOSED.

Discussion locked
Forum legend:
Locked Locked thread
Moderator Moderator
CNET staff CNET staff
Samsung staff Samsung staff
Norton Authorized Support team Norton Authorized Support team
AVG staff AVG staff
Windows Outreach team Windows Outreach team
Dell staff Dell staff
Intel staff Intel staff
Powered by Jive Software