"Is it just me are did Natali fit right in to Monday's episode?"
I have to disagree. She continues to interrupt other folks on the show. I will continue until Natali is removed from BOL.
So you just want Natali gone? You won't even give her a chance when others say she's getting better? And you won't stop posting the same complaint until she's gone from the show? I think you just lost all credibility. ![]()
That was much like other posts where people have said things like: "I fast-forwarded thru the last x episodes because I know they were bad". Or "I listen to the first coule minutes and if Natali is on then I delete because I know it's going to be bad".
Some people just have a drum to beat and they are not going to let their rhythm be affected by logic, common sense, or the even the possibility of change.
...we know they will stink. We don't need to subject ourselves to excruciating pain over and over again to know that something will hurt.
In fairness, you still need to recognize that you don't really KNOW that the movies you didn't see were just as bad--maybe lightning struck just once!--but it's a good point for sure.
My sense of the posts that I was referencing was that the people seemed to be offerering it as evidence--"I fast-forwarded because I knew they were bad, so that proves they were bad or else I would have listened"--circular-type silliness. They may not have been meant that way (and I don't know if you wrote any of the ones I'm talking about so I'm not intending to be personal here), but they came across that way to me.
First of all, I've been listening every day since BEFORE Veronica. 2005 I think is when I subscribed, and I've probably listened to 98%+ of the episodes. It's very much part of my daily routine.
I love the show, but I really don't think Natali is a good fit.
First, and NOT AT ALL BECAUSE SHE'S A FEMALE, I don't think she's nearly as well versed in technology as any other host or co-host, and I think at times that becomes very clear.
Second, she seems to be trying to step into somewhat leading BOL, which, (not to imply anyone is better than the others) has tended to be Tom's place. (I'm mainly thinking of segues and getting us back on topic.) Hopefully this isn't a future plan to phase Tom out, because Tom is the awesome. My point in this is only that she's trying to force her way in. When V and Jason joined, they slowly found their nich, and grew into that role, keeping the chemistry fully intact.
I'm not at all anti-Natali. I think she'd be great as a general population technology translator, but I really think the BOL audience is left wanting with her as one of the regular hosts. To be perfectly honest, without a regular cast, and with Natali in my opinion changing and/or hurting the show, I've been considering unsubscribing for a while.
I disagree with your statement that the BOL audience is left wanting if Natali is on the show. For every show, I feel satisfied after listening even if Natali is part of the cast.
In fact, the only episode that I felt really bored was episode 978: Blue screen of payment. Wow was that episode really dull, and it didn't have Natali in it. I really enjoy listening to her since she brings some sort of cheery tune to the show.
Plus, can someone give examples of Natali interrupting other hosts? because I don't understand that complaint. Maybe I don't notice it.
Hopefully, I would finally be played on the show if more of the people complaining unsubscribe. Love the show!
I totally agree you about not feeling Natali. I mean you can only watch and listen to her! Plus, that would be weird if you feel Natali. You might get arrested for that.
I guess you can touch the monitor, but that's feeling the monitor not Natali. Maybe haptic feedback was installed, we can feel Natali. Until then we can only watch and listen to her.
on just the last week episode. she talks about the palm pre, but can not discuss anything further because she signed legal papers. i'm getting tired of these briefings she has, but can not talk about it. its like kevin rose having inside connections about his the iphone and not talk about it on his show. ***??
Not just about Natali, but in general. If you can't talk about it, why mention it? She hasn't started name-dropping yet, has she?
A few weeks ago, I reformatted my computer. I just couldn't bring myself to subscribe anymore. I've enjoyed the show for about a year and a half, but as of late, it seems to be going downhill fast ever since Molly left. Natalie seems to be pulling the show off topic too much, and seems uninformed. I'm going to keep a eye on BOL to see if it improves, but for now I'm listening to Leo Laporte's Podcasts and Geek News Central....
Installed Windows 7 on my pc and just got a netbook and took the opportunity to sit down and decide which podcasts I really listen to and which I need to drop. I've dropped BOL from subscription and just check in a time or two a week to see if it's any better. I love the episodes where Natali isn't there. She was fine as a once a week guest, but can't hang with the others as a regular host.
Nothing proved this more than when Molly and Tom were both gone a month or so back and Natali was left to run the show. They were some of the worst episodes I've heard in the 18 months that I've been listening. If I want uninformed opinions, I'll talk to my non-tech friends. I tune into BOL for news, trends and informed opinions. I would love for Natali's agent to get her a job that takes her away from CNET. The fact that I know she has an agent is pathetic...who else on the show wastes time talking about their agent or the meetings that they arean't allowed to talk about?
She's obviously insecure if she needs to broadcast that she can't talk about something that she just brought up (i.e, the Pre.) Makes her seem, emphasis on SEEM, important.
We dont need to know about your non-disclosures, in fact, by signing the non-disclosure, you are useless for news on the Pre.
Please, please, please move on to CBS or whatever the heck your next stepping stone is.
I haven't listened to BOL in quite a few months. I just, for no apparent reason, thought I'd check in on the forums to see what I'd missed out on. By the looks of it BOL has gone to s**t. So many Natali haters! I've swapped over to the 404. Not because I want informed commentary. Just because I need a laugh! So without any further adieu...
Adios BOL. You will be missed.
David
I just heard Natali's announcement that she no longer will be a permanent host on the show. She's dropping monday, thursday and friday now.
Does this decision of hers have got anything to do with this forum thread?
I believe this will be a more balanced set up, we will see/hear more Molly, and more of everybody else. YAY!
Works for me.
| Forum legend: | |
| Locked thread | |
| Moderator | |
![]() |
CNET staff |
![]() |
Samsung staff |
| Norton Authorized Support team | |
| AVG staff | |
| Windows Outreach team | |
![]() |
Dell staff |
| Intel staff | |