Find the perfect gift for everyone
Buzz Out Loud Lounge: What if... (constructive criticism for BOL)...
What if... (constructive criticism for BOL)...
by shmody - 4/21/09 12:25 PMWhat if... (constructive criticism for BOL)...
To provide constructive criticism to CBS/CNET, please add your idea to making the show great again (in the case you think it's lost something and have lost patience with the warming up period with the variety of changes).
Please add you idea below.
Vive le BOL! 
--Shalin
del Conti / Ogg / Cooper takes out Dvorak, Pouge, Mossberg..
by shmody - 4/21/09 12:28 PM In reply to: What if... (constructive criticism for BOL)... by shmodydel Conti / Ogg / Cooper takes out Dvorak, Pouge, Mossberg..
Personally, I'd LOVE to hear a weekly 15-20 minute news and commentary podcast with Natali (del Conti), Erica (Ogg), and Charlie (Cooper). Q-U-A-L-I-T-Y stuff would result I'm sure that could take down Dvorak, Pouge, and even Mossberg!!!!!
I think this character mix is rather good as far as journalism, professionalism, and personality goes.
CBS/CNET - rumble in the tech-jungle! del Conti/Ogg/Cooper vs. Dvorak vs. Pouge vs. Mossberg!
Best,
Shalin
oh yeah, for BOL - more...
by shmody - 4/21/09 12:32 PM In reply to: del Conti / Ogg / Cooper takes out Dvorak, Pouge, Mossberg.. by shmodyoh yeah, for BOL - more...Cooley, Tong, Bonnie Cha, Nicole Lee, and/or Jasmine France. If I had to replace Natali's position, it would be a toss up between Bonnie and Jasmine with Nicole as a close second.
--S
Introduction to BOL newbies...
by shmody - 4/22/09 8:30 AM In reply to: oh yeah, for BOL - more... by shmodyIntroduction to BOL newbies...
In case you don't know me too well, here's a little speall.
I'd say I've been empowered BOL listener since Spring 2006. I say empowered 'cause I feel I get some unique insight on BOL that isn't found elsewhere. I've found it to be the most useful and entertaining tech news show and garners my precious time before other tech news.
Since the Spring of 2006 I've tremendously enjoyed listening, contributing, and even getting together with others BOLers (in the *First* Life, for realz I think this is a wonderful community - online or not. I especially like that when there's a debate, at least most of the time, we're all just trying to get to bottom of something and fully understand each other. I find that giving respect, insight, and LOLs are crucial to maintaining this community's foundation.
I also find that from time to time the listenership needs to "rise up" and refocus/redirect/re-something-er-other the show. The hosts and producer typically do a GREAT job listening and responding to the audience.
However, now the audience sorta includes CBS shareholders. Now, I'm not saying we should rant/rail against the CBS corporation, but rather, I believe, this could very well be a well timed opportunity to show how well a clever, strong, innovative, diverse, community can rebound and get hummin' again after being a bit out of rhythm. I mean...this is really just walking the walk of what is presented in the BOL podcast and what we frequently discuss on this forum, yes?
So, let's roll up our sleeves and put in some thought out ideas - yes? Post a forward looking idea here:
http://forums.cnet.com/5208-10152_102-0.html?threadID=339950
Best,
Shalin
Empowered BOL listener since Spring 2006
"Momma" and "Old man" of Buzztown
P.S. - No need for others to jump on to bolster this intro, just get goin' and add a forward looking idea to the thread! Go Buzztown!
What happened Shalin?
by Alegoo92 - 4/25/09 8:23 AM In reply to: Introduction to BOL newbies... by shmodyI'll admit. I stopped listening a good while ago...stopped listening every day post-Veronica.. then tried to get into it through intermittent episodes I'd download. After a recurring theme of Molly being away, I just lost interest altogether.
So what's happened now? Are our veteran hosts done with the show, or has it been so bastardized by CBS that it doesn't feel like BOL?
I'm not really a listener anymore, but I'm still concerned for the show that brought me into the world of tech-- especially if it's at the expense of it's amazing listener-audience.
- Alex
well for me: house hunting, community service & work happnd.
by shmody - 4/25/09 9:21 AM In reply to: What happened Shalin? by Alegoo92that's all. My reduced listening isn't for lack of interest. I check the line up pretty much everyday to see of any particular stories I'd like the BOL crews comments on (whoever is part of the crew that day). but yeah, I just got really busy with misc. stuff - especially house hunting (now owning/maintaining), Big Brother/Sisters, a financial literacy meetup group I started, and work...
--S
OMG, my bad - skimmed your post too fast. what happnd was..
by shmody - 4/28/09 12:24 PM In reply to: well for me: house hunting, community service & work happnd. by shmodyOMG, my bad - skimmed your post too fast. what happened was a BOL crew change and while the crew is still providing great content, the dialogue/banter/chemistry has a new vibe that a lot of long-time listeners don't entirely enjoy, they miss the old vibe, and want something to be done...
--S
Since you asked...
by Slikkster - 4/23/09 6:27 AM In reply to: oh yeah, for BOL - more... by shmodyYou asked in my other "I'm unsubscribing" thread to post an idea before I went. But first, may I say that I'm disappointed with you, Shalin. This thread (as I read it, anyway) seems to be a thinly-veiled "Natali must go" thread. Sure, you post your ideas for her in some kind of three-way newsfest, but that's not BOL. Am I incorrect in reading that you're thinking she'd be best OFF BOL and in some other kind of format? If so, then how about stating that clearly? If I'm mistaken, accept my apology for misaprehending. But just be upfront about it, rather than couching it in a roundabout way.
In my view, the best thing that could be done with the show in its current format is to move Natali to the west coast so she could be in studio. Being "on remote" all the time is one of the biggest impediments to good social interaction. There's no immediate visual cues, and audio --even though it's not too delayed with the proper ISDN algorithm--is still clumsy. Plus, there's no opportunity for her to really get to know her co-hosts on a more personal level, as in off the show. And, vice-versa. That is a very important component to the team concept. <b>She needs to be in-studio with the rest.</b>
If that doesn't fit with her life/career, or the company's plans, then some kind of decision should be made, in my view, to find a female host on the west coast who is tech savvy and has the right personality to hold up her end of the conversation. I don't know who that is right now. But in the meantime, the best thing they could do --assuming no personnel changes are in the offing-- is to get Natali relocated so she's local to the show. I think that would do wonders for the repartee. Yeah, I know, some people will say "but she's been in studio before". But an occasional visit isn't what I'm talking about. I'm talking about becoming part of the same community as the other hosts, professionally, personally and geographically.
So, there ya go. And here I go. Ciao for now.
Okay, I'll say it explicitly then...
by shmody - 4/23/09 7:06 AM In reply to: Since you asked... by SlikksterOkay, I'll say it explicitly then - I think Natali should not be in the daily BOL line-up at this time and at least for the *immediate* future (like, say the next 3-4 months). This is because I enjoy a different vibe than the show is delivering with the Natali as a daily host.
And I totally agree with the this East/West coast studio issue - it really does seem to be an underrated/sleeper issue.
Best wishes Slikkster! Come back and drop us a line sometime
--S
additionally...
by shmody - 4/23/09 7:12 AM In reply to: Okay, I'll say it explicitly then... by shmody>> This is because I enjoy a different vibe than the show is delivering with the Natali as a daily host.
Considering both the several changes to BOL in the last few months as well as realizing that "you can never go home again" (i.e., if time has gone by, you can't just "reset" everything and expect the "good old days"), I feel that the best course of action would be to use Natali's talents and personality on a regular (i.e. daily) basis elsewhere within CNET.
Very best,
Shalin
P.S. - You're correct Slikkster, the original post was not as clear as it could have been. Thanks for keepin' me honest.
although, if there are great "Natali should stay if ___"
by shmody - 4/23/09 8:40 AM In reply to: additionally... by shmodyalthough, if there are great "Natali should stay if ___" scenarios, I'd be happy to know of them...but my reason for posting was that
1) Although there have been many changes over the years the show has been on, nowadays many, many BOL listeners are not enjoying the show as we used to - so, as I see it, *something* has gotta change with the show. Although the listernship are the customers, to be pragmatic, we should also adjust/give-it-a-chance *some* amount to changes to get the enjoyment and insight once delivered.
2) to have a space/thread to put *forward looking* ideas, regardless of if "Natali should stay or go", etc. I thought there's been enough commentary, thought, and emotion - so this is an attempt of a vehicle to move forward on...
3) I did include "(in the case you think it's lost something and have lost patience with the warming up period with the variety of changes)." because for those that think the show is *not* fine or better than it used to be and I wanted to redirect that thought and energy to something constructive (see #2 above). I do admit, this is not *primarily* meant to be a thread for those that think the show is fine/better than it used to be - but all comments *having to do with the theme of this thread* are welcome.
maybe this could've been a simple "Is the show as enjoyable or more enjoyable than it was several months ago? If not, what forward looking idea would you propose?" thing... but, we're at where we're at...
Okay, I think I've put it all out there now.
Best,
Shalin
Thanks
by Slikkster - 4/23/09 9:55 AM In reply to: although, if there are great "Natali should stay if ___" by shmodyYou have been quite clear and explicit, and that's all I can ask. I can't quarrel with your opinions, and I have enormous respect for you. And, I'm sure your comments carry weight with at least some principals on the show.
There's an old saying in politics that goes something like "If you've lost <insert your core constituency here>, you've lost everything. That just might be the case if BOL sees your unequivocal stand on matters as they are. Don't get a swelled head about it, but I know they've always valued your input and no doubt your opinions. And if they've lost Shalin...
I'll check back in awhile to see what's going on. Best to you.
My take
by hosko - 4/26/09 8:41 AM In reply to: although, if there are great "Natali should stay if ___" by shmodyAs a TV director I'm use to having to deal with talent being in different studios trying to talk to each other. We (Producer and Director) try to get around the issue by talking into their ears (IFB's) and telling everybody who is asking the next question. But it is never as good as when everybody is in the one studio. The chat is just never natural.
Now in BOL's case I would say in my professional opinion that it is impossible to get around these limitations because you don't have a dedicated team in the background directing the flow of the conversation. It is up to the on-air talent to perform this function with the producer also on-air. The end result being that on every episode and usually multiple times in each the guys in the west coast studio talk over Nat or she talks over one of them. This then results in a couple of seconds of dead air and then a discussion on who is going to talk. This just kills the flow of the conversation and becomes highly annoying to the listener. Then add in the worse situation of the link between East and West dropping out the conversation continuing then when the link is re-established Nat continues to say what she was saying even though that exact point had just been discussed for the past minute.
I also believe that their is very little to gain from having a full time voice in NY and the rest of the team out West. Sure get someone to be on the show in NY if there is a big story that they will have something to ADD.
I really don't get why you guys are trying to make the show more complicated then it should be. People enjoy the simplicity of the show, 3 people sitting around a table discussing tech news. I really got into the show because of the terrific conversation that it use to have.
Go back to basics, as the old saying goes KEEP IT SIMPLE STUPID.
Good input, thx; what about two crews?...
by shmody - 4/26/09 11:29 AM In reply to: My take by hoskoGood input, thx; what about two crews?...
I was thinking about this time-delay issue and thought, what if you had at least knowledgeable two people in the West coast studio and NYC studio each.
Given that, you may actually be able to basically assign which studio handles a story/description and it's commentary. Additional/last thoughts can be given by the other studio after the "lead" studio is done.
Or maybe the lead studio provides the story/description, the supporting studio provides questions/commentary, and the lead studio does a wrap-up.
It's kind of a band-aid thing, but it may be workable. Thoughts?
--S
...
by hosko - 4/27/09 8:15 AM In reply to: Good input, thx; what about two crews?... by shmodyshmody wrote:
"Given that, you may actually be able to basically assign which studio handles a story/description and it's commentary. Additional/last thoughts can be given by the other studio after the "lead" studio is done."
Then you don't have the guests engaging in conversation. I just don't see the point, its not like CNET doesn't have enough knowledgeable staff in the one location. If you are going to have two crews you might as well bang out two different podcasts instead of one.
I think the two studio issue is a big one. Listen to the eps when Jason was on NY and you'll hear a massive improvement in the conversation between Nat and Jason, that just proves my point.
Guys you tried it, your audience including very loyal long term ones don't like it, fix it and move on.
| Forum legend: | |
 |
Locked thread |
 |
Moderator |
 |
CNET staff |
 |
Samsung staff |
 |
Norton Authorized Support team |
 |
AVG staff |
 |
Windows Outreach team |
 |
Dell staff |
 |
Intel staff |
