Version: 2008
Advanced Search
advertisement
advertisement

Forum display:

Community Newsletter: Q&A: Home audio and video: Premium vs. generic cables

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) Moderator - 6/15/07 6:51 AM
advertisement
Post 121 of 201

QOTW 053207 bus Answer

by acoxon1274 - 6/7/07 12:19 PM In reply to: Home audio and video: Premium vs. generic cables by Lee Koo (ADMIN) Moderator

Question
Alright, so I've been trying to become involved in the high-definition era for a few years now. As far as I'm concerned, picking the right cables can be controversial. Whenever you go buy a new HDTV or an accessory component, the salesmen always ask if you have the appropriate connections. Then they always ask if you have "the best" connections that will provide the optimal picture and sound. So is there? Is a $15 cable going to provide equivalent performance to a $100 cable of the same type? And does this question have a different answer for analog and digital cables? I'd love to get the facts straight once and for all. Thanks! --Submitted by Derek M.

Answer
A good salesperson should ask you questions that produce the best choices for you that will allow your system to function at its highest performance level within your price range and living environment. In this busy world we live in, the sales interview is too time consuming to take place properly and the more common practice is the buyer finds the components/system at the best price and buys at the location of convenience with the understanding that the some system of cabling is included or in the case that no cabling is included the cheapest cabling available is bought to just make sure the system works.

After the components/system has been found to be functional the fine tuning of its performance becomes a consumer need, usually brought on by ads and a nagging feeling of having missed something along the way (what are all the connections on the back for). One of the areas that a consumer can upgrade at the component or system level is the cabling, just due to the fact that cabling doesn’t require a great deals of skill and tools. The industry/marketplace answers the need by providing cabling at various price levels. Once the marketplace has enough statistics a comfort price range is established usually incorporating, low end, good, and high end with very little reflection on true quality.

The final point, is your satisfaction. With most reliable vendors, you can buy what you want with the understanding you can and will return items your are unsatisfied with. So the next time you are faced with a salesperson asking the question “do you have "the best" connections that will provide the optimal picture and sound?” listen and then tell them you will take both with the understanding that you will return what is unsatisfactory. Take the purchases home and see what you think and based on that return what you don’t like. When you are using your components/system you are using your analog receptor systems that you were born with. The components/system is passing the signal through an analog medium (the speaker and display) so you can experience it as a reproduction of the original media. The only time digital comes into play is when the reproduction of the original media requires conversion from digital to analog to allow you to experience it. Until we can be equipped with digital input jacks you should not worry yourself about the shape and size of ones and zeros.

Post 122 of 201

Huh?

by drew30319 - 6/8/07 6:40 PM In reply to: QOTW 053207 bus Answer by acoxon1274

Am I the only one that can't follow bus's answer?

Post 123 of 201

In agreement

by flybaer - 6/8/07 6:54 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

I will have to agree with you. It was difficult to follow.

Post 124 of 201

Huh and double Huh?

by stane cauld - 6/8/07 7:18 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

Indeed you're not the only one!
I think that whatever sense may have been in bus's answer was totally lost in his inabillity to string proper grammar together. I'm in no way a pedant but it does help to at least say what you mean!

Post 125 of 201

But does that matter? He's winning in the poll ...... <eom>

by Watzman - 6/8/07 7:21 PM In reply to: Huh and double Huh? by stane cauld

But does that matter? He's winning in the poll ...... <eom>

Post 126 of 201

Winning the poll?

by stane cauld - 6/8/07 7:35 PM In reply to: But does that matter? He's winning in the poll ...... <eom> by Watzman

Of course it matters! Look at politicians. There's always one who wins the poll and you can bet your sweet ass it's always the one with no brains...and I in no way mean to say that bus is without brains!

Post 127 of 201

He's winning because he's first

by richchrono - 6/8/07 7:52 PM In reply to: But does that matter? He's winning in the poll ...... <eom> by Watzman

Particularly with long posts, readers won't read all the posts to the end and will stop at the first one (or so) that they agree with.
In short, the longer the posts, the more likely the first choice will get the most votes.
I agree with the previous responses. I thought his answer was the least informative.

Post 128 of 201

poll influenced by bad wording in email

by GP7 - 6/9/07 12:28 AM In reply to: But does that matter? He's winning in the poll ...... <eom> by Watzman

I just wanted to read all of the answers and clicked the first one in the email, which simply said "answer by bus". I ended up voting for an answer I never read. If the hyperlinks said "Vote for [name's] answer" I'll bet there would be a difference in the poll results.

Personally I would just put voting hyperlinks near the full answer, so you can't accidentally vote for one you never read.

Post 129 of 201

Oh Boy!

by louisechaney - 6/9/07 4:55 AM In reply to: Huh and double Huh? by stane cauld

Bus must be that guy that sells you those highly expensive cables.

Post 130 of 201

I don't think he actually answered the question...

by grtgrfx - 6/8/07 7:22 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

but it sounded sincere.

Post 131 of 201

:))

by slydoggydogg68 - 6/8/07 7:45 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

Not only it did not make sense, it is NOT USABLE as well... He states, as with many vendors, you can take items u r not happy back...

You will take wires from the within walls, make a mess, and run new cables? How about just rebuilding your house, once u r at it? The question is a smart one, the answer is NOT! The decision MUST BE MADE PRIOR to purchase, since then it will be too late (After installation)

Post 132 of 201

Yes, I get the picture or hear the sound for that matter....

by gfoley1 - 6/8/07 8:34 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

It makes sense, again, it makes great sense to buy several types of cables and see which ones your "eyes and ears" like best". Then, of course, make sure you can take the ones you do not like back to the store for a full refund. Simple, I don't see the hang up.

Great note to remember: If any store will refund you a full refund for any product you are not satisfied with, then by all means buy multiple items and test them all -- after which you can take back the ones that do not work to your satisfaction! Simple.

It all makes simple sense, let us not get complex here.

Post 133 of 201

What do you mean "I don't see the hang up"?

by jjohnsonsr - 6/9/07 9:13 AM In reply to: Yes, I get the picture or hear the sound for that matter.... by gfoley1

It's simple like you said, but the difference between your answer and the other guy up there is the time it took to say what you said! You basically said what he said in 2 little paragraphs. It took him 4 paragraphs and a lot of useless babbling to answer a question! So, thats what all the hang up is all about. Keeping whats simple, SIMPLE!

Post 134 of 201

Huh?

by rahjr2 - 6/9/07 12:24 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

No, you aren't.

Post 135 of 201

Cable upgrades

by 1celtic1 - 6/10/07 6:18 PM In reply to: Huh? by drew30319

I think that the Bus has long ago left the station with his answer still intact.I have NO idea what he was talking about...

Forum legend:
Locked Locked thread
Moderator Moderator
CNET staff CNET staff
Samsung staff Samsung staff
Norton Authorized Support team Norton Authorized Support team
AVG staff AVG staff
Windows Outreach team Windows Outreach team
Dell staff Dell staff
Intel staff Intel staff
Powered by Jive Software