Version: 2008
  • On ZDNet: Why Linux isn't enough
Advanced Search
advertisement
advertisement

Forum display:

Miscellaneous laptop discussions : Don't buy alienware.

by tiddlesworth - 8/24/06 10:40 PM
advertisement
Post 1 of 5

Don't buy alienware.

by tiddlesworth - 8/24/06 10:40 PM

Here is why:

Approximately last may, I purchased a Sentia 223 laptop from alienware, it cost considerably more than a comparable competing laptop, but I figured the extra speed and customizability would be worth it. It ended up being just shy of four grand canadian. Thinking ahead, I bought the 2 year extended warranty, reasoning that every other computer I have had either had problems right away, or just after the one year mark.

About a week ago, my computer started to spontaneously die during normal use, shortly after that it would fail to boot: In a nutshell, the 80 gig hard drive went. After a lengthy step by step (and multiple day) process to convince the tech support that the hard drive was in fact dying, they sent me a new one under warranty -and billed me for it-. Their reasoning is that the billing would not go through if I shipped them back the defective hard drive within five days of receiving the new one. This is my only computer at the moment, and I don't know about you but it takes a lot longer than five days to recover from a hard disk failure, especially when you are at work 10-12 hours a day. Doubly so when you have to order a special part online that will allow you to attempt to recover any data. I contacted their customer service department to request an extension so that I could wait until the part I need to connect the hard drive via the USB port arrives so I can get my data off. Note that I cannot ship the hard drive to them now without taking a hammer to it, as there is confidential data on it. I was informed by their customer service department that all they could do was send an e-mail to their rebate department with my request, but that there was no guarantee that I would not be billed.

After successfully installing the hard drive, the battery immediately died. The first time I had ever taken it out of the laptop after putting it in when the laptop was shipped to me was in order to remove the panel over the hard drive so that I could replace it. At first the system would see the hard drive, but would be unable to boot without the AC in, and the laptop would not charge past 7%. If I were to suddenly unplug the laptop (I did this once, it is how i first noticed the problem when I was moving the laptop to a cat5 cable because I needed to download the wireless driver) the laptop would immediately die.

Another call to technical support, another lengthy procedure wherein I was told to hot swap the battery (charge went from 7% to 1%), and then take the battery out and leave it out for 24 hours before placing it in the PC again and seeing if the battery would reboot, for lack of a better term. A few minutes ago, I get off the phone with tech support: The battery is not covered any longer -even under the extended warranty- and will cost about $80 dollars to replace. This contradicting what the original tech guy I talked to told me: that the battery would be replaced if defective.

As an aside, when I bought this computer, a friend of mine bought one nearly identical to it only with the 1.6 instead of 1.8ghs processor. His laptop was riddled with problems including a defective display and motherboard, and it took him months to get it set up, including I might add opening the laptop and fiddling with the cabling with the instruction of an on the phone tech guy. Is it just me or should the laptop come assembled properly? Oh, and the rebates took much longer than stated to arrive.

On the plus side, I did not have to wait for more than a few minutes to speak to one of their tech support guys. Thus far, that has been the only plus of owning this laptop, and really, ideally I would spend no time on the phone with them at all. I would heartily recommend you purchase a toshiba or HP laptop as I and everyone I know has had positive experiences with them, but given the propensity for Alienware machines to die shortly after their warranties expire and given the crappy coverage of the warranty to begin with (even when you spend a couple hundred bucks to extend it), I will not be buying an Alienware again, and I suggest you don't buy one to begin with.

Cheers,

-Steve

Post 2 of 5

that's quite an experience.

by udayan71 Moderator - 8/25/06 6:06 AM In reply to: Don't buy alienware. by tiddlesworth

Nevertheless I wouldn't rule out an entire company because of a couple of bad products. Seeing as both of you had bad Sentia 223s, it could be that this model was not getting the same Q&A attention.

I don't own any Alienware stuff but I know a guy who has the big 17" Area 51 machine and he loves it.

I hope you have better luck elsewhere, I do think that there was a problem with both machines you describe but I don't think all Alienware products would fare so badly.

Udayan.

Post 3 of 5

Client's son's experience with desktop

by tcantrelln - 8/25/06 8:22 AM In reply to: Don't buy alienware. by tiddlesworth

Told him beforehand- do not call us, do not ask us, if you have a problem, call Alienware. It's now about fourteen months old, probably hasn't run five days in a row without something failing or just absolutely doing wierd. It's going to be in their garage sale this weekend. $100 or free after noon Saturday.

Post 4 of 5

Not directed to any of the owners but for new buyer thinking

by Qosmio - 8/27/06 3:39 PM In reply to: Client's son's experience with desktop by tcantrelln

of going alianware--you must wake up and not get ripped off.yes it,s a pretty notebook packed with power yet lack of quilty and 0 teck support should be the your real concern in the purchase of a pc.If you choose to take the gamble on alianware be sure to get a good tool set to take it apart and do the fixing yourself while there support gets a kink out of it.A sales rep I work with brother did teck support for alianware.They do place bets on some of there customers so maybe you will be a winner.
GOOD LUCK

Post 5 of 5

The problem is

by nino88 - 8/27/06 4:47 PM In reply to: Not directed to any of the owners but for new buyer thinking by Qosmio

that many magazines are quite bias when reviewing companies and computers. For example, when PC Magazine and Laptop magazine review super systems, they always include Alienware computers in the articles. Of course they placed among the top systems. But when they reviewed the tech support (I think it's laptop magazine), they didn't include Alienware at all. Why?? I have yet to read one negative comment from those magazines regarding Alienware except high price.

2 years back I was also a victim of their $3k+ notebook. It was an ugly experience too with their customer service.

Forum legend:
Locked Locked thread
Moderator Moderator
CNET staff CNET staff
Samsung staff Samsung staff
Norton Authorized Support team Norton Authorized Support team
AVG staff AVG staff
Windows Outreach team Windows Outreach team
Dell staff Dell staff
Intel staff Intel staff
Powered by Jive Software