Version: 2008
  • On GameSpot: So-called 'Halo killer' gets 23 to life
Advanced Search
advertisement
advertisement

Featuring CNET Editor Wayne Cunningham

Sponsored by Best Buy

Safe at all speeds: Car safety technologies Session has ended.

Missed this live event? No worries! Each Thursday from 11 a.m. to noon Pacfic, we'll give you the chance to chat live with a CNET editor. We'll cover a new topic each week, from cell phones to TVs. Get those burning tech questions ready! Click here for the Ask the Editor Live event calendar.

Latest questions and answers

Q: 2009 TSX...

by akl8806 - 5/22/08 12:09 PM

Are you guys going to review the new Acura TSX 2009 any time soon? Because I have to say, Acura gave the new TSX a tech boost...

Would you get this or the new Audi A4?

A: TSX

by wcunning - 5/22/08 12:16 PM

Yes, I have the new TSX on the schedule for early July, so look for the review then.

Q: safety ratings

by kwhsy82 - 5/22/08 12:02 PM

Who puts out the best safety ratings for car?

Are there any particular ratings within that system you focus on?

Also, if I may ask another question:

How much is bigger, safer? E.g. Prius has good safety ratings, but I still feel safer in my Escape...

A: safety ratings

by wcunning - 5/22/08 12:15 PM

See my previous answer for some of these issues. The government's transportation department regulates safety testing, and offers 5 star crash ratings at www.safercar.gov. As for small cars vs. big cars, one advantage that small cars have is that they bounce off things. There is less inertia, so instead of plowing the car, and you, further into the mass of metal you have hit, they are more likely than a heavier car to bounce back. But as an example of the excellent safety of modern cars, I saw an F1 race where one of the drivers went off track, hit a wall, then cartwheeled back across the track to the other wall. Of course the car was destroyed, but the driver only suffered a broken ankle. That F1 car was much lighter than an Escape, but still protected the driver. And the safety engineering in the F1 car is similar to what you find in modern passenger cars.

Q: Mini Cooper S and RAV 4...

by akl8806 - 5/22/08 11:59 AM

2 days ago I was test driving a Mini Cooper S and I test drove both the automatic and manual and quite honestly both are equally FUN. The reason I test drove the automatic also was because my sister was with me at the time and she can't drive a manual quite well. Also my sister is shopping for a new car and she cannot decide between a Toyota RAV 4 Sport V-6 or the Mini Cooper S. Anyways (some of these questions are from my sis) here the questions...

1) How safe really are the Mini Coopers? And what makes them so safe?

2) Have you test drove a JCW Mini Cooper S? How was it? Are there any major differences between a regular Mini Cooper S and JCW Mini Cooper S?

3) Why did Mini change the S model engine from a supercharger to a turbocharger? Does it increase fuel economy or what?

4) What are your gripes about the Mini Cooper?

5) Does the Rav 4 come with AWD?

6) RAV 4 or Mini Cooper S? hahaha

Thanx for reading

akl8806

A: RAV4 and Mini Cooper

by wcunning - 5/22/08 12:10 PM

There's a myth that small cars aren't safe, but if you look at the crash ratings (www.safercar.gov), you will often find that small cars do just as well as large cars in a crash. Modern engineering such as safety cages and crumple zones help keep all cars safe. I've driven the JCW Mini, and honestly, I don't think it's worth the money. It is certainly fun, and you can outrun a standard Cooper S, but I can't see paying $40k for a Mini. As for the turbocharger, I suspect it was largely due to cost, as turbochargers are less complex than superchargers. I can't think of any real gripes I have about the Mini. It's a fun car with a good practical side, as long as it is roomy enough for you. You can get the RAV4 with all-wheel-drive.

Q: What's the coolest safety feature you've seen?

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:39 AM

Wayne, you've been to numerous car shows, test driven gazillion cars... in your opinion what is the coolest safety feature you've come across that you think is not only the coolest, but also be a high selling point for a car.

A: coolest safety tech

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:43 AM

I'm pretty impressed by radar systems that sense if you are about to crash into a car in front of you, and do things like hit the brakes, tighten the seatbelts, etc. I experienced that feature once just driving in traffic in the city, when the car thought I was about to hit another car stopped at a light. In reality, I was about to hit the brakes, just a little later than the car wanted. But it was interesting to feel the seatbelts tighten. Also, I think the most useful is Volvo's blind spot warning.

Q: How about..

by haub123 - 5/22/08 11:29 AM

which is safer. volvo s80 acura rl, or the lexus gs? thanks.

A: safest car?

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:33 AM

good question. each car has good safety attributes, and you could look up their crash safety ratings, which I don't know off-hand. I would assume those ratings are about the same across these cars. the Acura has all-wheel-drive, which is definitely a benefit. Volvo is offering good safety tech such as blind spot warning, keeping you from changing lanes into another car. The GS is a good all-around car, and has an excellent road-holding tech called VDIM.

Q: Honda commercials on not only protecting us inside

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:26 AM

I've seen the commercial from Honda about not only protecting the folks inside of their cars, but also protecting the people who are outside the cars --in an instance where you hit a pedestrian... If you have any info on that, I would love to hear about it... but if you don't no worries.

A: pedestrian safety

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:26 AM

Europeans are doing much more to ensure pedestrian safety by regulating the design of cars, for example. I think it is Jaguar that actually put a system under the hood designed to cushion the blow if the car were to hit a pedestrian.

Q: Car safety features for kids?

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:16 AM

Currently our cars have teathering for child car seats, but nothing beyond that. Have you seen anything in cars that address child safety?

A: kid safety

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:18 AM

the only really electronic feature focused on kids are the weight sensors on the passenger seat, that can tell if an adult is sitting in the seat and will activate the usual safety precautions. If it's not an adult in the seat, the car won't deploy air bags.

Q: Re: to the Ex35 Interesting....

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:12 AM

So when you cross over the line, does it warn you or does it automatically correct the steering to keep you within the lanes?

A: EX35 lane control

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:14 AM

The cool thing is that it doesn't control the steering at all. If it detects that you are going over the lane line, it activates the opposite side brakes for a brief moment, which nudges the car back into its lane.

Q: Wayne how does the technology work for EX35?

by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:08 AM

How does the car know you're drifting out of the lane?

A: EX35

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:09 AM

Infiniti put cameras under the side mirrors that monitor the lane lines. In our testing, it did a very good job of accurately recognizing when we crossed over lane lines.

A: Greetings

by wcunning - 5/22/08 11:01 AM

With Volvo working on technologies to build the 'uncrashable' car and an Infiniti EX35 we tested recently featuring technology that keeps you from drifting out of your lane, how much control of your car are you willing to hand over in the name of safety?

Ask a question

Welcome to the Ask the Editors Live! In order to submit a question to our editor, we ask that you either log in with your current CNET account or register with us. Registration is free and easy- sign up now and join in on the discussion!

Incoming questions

Mini Cooper Safety...
I would like to ask a safety question beyond the ones below.

When looking at the crash ratings from the government's crash tests, aren't the tests simply demonstrating what the crash would be if a Mini Cooper hit an identically sized car? The reality is, the car will be substantially larger.

Are there any statistics on survival or injury rates in real-world crashes with the Mini Cooper? I would love to get one but I do a lot of highway driving and assume a crash on the highway in a Mini Cooper would be an ugly crash, regardless of the airbags, safety cage and crumble zones (not much to crumble!). Do you agree? The bouncing effect sounds interesting...but on a highway? Hitting an SUV at 70 or 80mpg?

One last question: I live in Michigan and am wondering how such a small car would fare on ice and in snow? I assume the front wheel drive would be beneficial but wonder how the weight of the car factors in.

Thank you.
by susie48009 - 7/22/08 5:42 AM
2009 TSX...
Are you guys going to review the new Acura TSX 2009 any time soon? Because I have to say, Acura gave the new TSX a tech boost...

Would you get this or the new Audi A4?
by akl8806 - 5/22/08 12:09 PM
safety ratings
Who puts out the best safety ratings for car?

Are there any particular ratings within that system you focus on?

Also, if I may ask another question:

How much is bigger, safer? E.g. Prius has good safety ratings, but I still feel safer in my Escape...
by kwhsy82 - 5/22/08 12:02 PM
Mini Cooper S and RAV 4...
2 days ago I was test driving a Mini Cooper S and I test drove both the automatic and manual and quite honestly both are equally FUN. The reason I test drove the automatic also was because my sister was with me at the time and she can't drive a manual quite well. Also my sister is shopping for a new car and she cannot decide between a Toyota RAV 4 Sport V-6 or the Mini Cooper S. Anyways (some of these questions are from my sis) here the questions...

1) How safe really are the Mini Coopers? And what makes them so safe?

2) Have you test drove a JCW Mini Cooper S? How was it? Are there any major differences between a regular Mini Cooper S and JCW Mini Cooper S?

3) Why did Mini change the S model engine from a supercharger to a turbocharger? Does it increase fuel economy or what?

4) What are your gripes about the Mini Cooper?

5) Does the Rav 4 come with AWD?

6) RAV 4 or Mini Cooper S? hahaha

Thanx for reading

akl8806
by akl8806 - 5/22/08 11:59 AM
What's the coolest safety feature you've seen?
Wayne, you've been to numerous car shows, test driven gazillion cars... in your opinion what is the coolest safety feature you've come across that you think is not only the coolest, but also be a high selling point for a car.
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:39 AM
How about..
which is safer. volvo s80 acura rl, or the lexus gs? thanks.
by haub123 - 5/22/08 11:29 AM
Honda commercials on not only protecting us inside
I've seen the commercial from Honda about not only protecting the folks inside of their cars, but also protecting the people who are outside the cars --in an instance where you hit a pedestrian... If you have any info on that, I would love to hear about it... but if you don't no worries.
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:26 AM
Car safety features for kids?
Currently our cars have teathering for child car seats, but nothing beyond that. Have you seen anything in cars that address child safety?
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:16 AM
Re: to the Ex35 Interesting....
So when you cross over the line, does it warn you or does it automatically correct the steering to keep you within the lanes?
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:12 AM
Wayne how does the technology work for EX35?
How does the car know you're drifting out of the lane?
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/22/08 11:08 AM
Wayne Cunningham, CNET Car Tech editor live!
Ask the Editors Live! event.
Topic: Safe at all speeds: Car safety technologies

Got car safety tech questions? Need some advice or answers? Well, you've come to the right place. For one whole hour on Thursday, May 22, from 11 a.m. to noon Pacific Time, CNET's Car Tech editor, Wayne Cunningham, will be here to discuss and answer your questions on new car safety technologies--ranging from blind spot warning detection, crash mitigation, to traction and stability control, and more!

So if you got questions about new car safety technologies or curious on how they work, Wayne has answers! Don't miss out!

Click here for upcoming Ask the Editors Live events and past transcripts of events.
by Lee Koo (ADMIN) - 5/21/08 12:16 PM