Version: 2008
  • On MovieTome: See the villain of IRON MAN 2!
Advanced Search
advertisement

Forum display:

Buzz Out Loud Lounge: Legislation that would force your camera phone to click...

by robstak - 1/26/09 2:17 PM
advertisement
Post 1 of 25

Legislation that would force your camera phone to click...

by robstak - 1/26/09 2:17 PM

http://news.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=09%2F01%2F26%2F1846209&from=rss

"A new bill is being introduced called the Camera Phone Predator Alert Act, which would require any mobile phone containing a digital camera to sound a tone whenever a photograph is taken with the phone's camera. It would also prohibit such a phone from being equipped with a means of disabling or silencing the tone."

=====

This is bull-hockey. if you are a predator you'll figure out a way to get around this like i dunno headphones or cutting the wire to the speakerphone. dont penalize the country cuz of a few sickos
-k

Post 2 of 25

(NT) Aren't there hungry people to be fed?

by kwahhn - 1/26/09 2:46 PM In reply to: Legislation that would force your camera phone to click... by robstak

Post 3 of 25

exactly

by mementh - 1/26/09 5:52 PM In reply to: (NT) Aren't there hungry people to be fed? by kwahhn

this is meant to just "feel good" and just like any other feel good legislation there will be ways to defeate it since there are ways to disable it no matter what.

so please stop being silly and just punish those that misuse the equipment.

(plus what about areas that your taking pics like a kids play or recitle where such noise is bad, did anyone think of that?)

Post 4 of 25

The noise can be embarrassing...

by hollyhock - 1/28/09 8:33 AM In reply to: exactly by mementh

When I first got my current phone I hadn't gone through and really set everything up yet. This would include disabling the camera sound. It just wasn't first on my list of things to do.

That quickly changed when I was in the restroom at my office one day with the phone in my pocket. I had forgotten to lock the keys and the camera went off in my pocket. I had to hide in the stall until everyone was gone. Didn't want my coworkers thinking I was taking pictures in the bathroom!

I agree with the above... punish the offenders and not everyone. I think it would also be a bad thing for people who have used their cameras to capture "in the act" things and given the images to police. Would you want to snap a picture on the subway or bus of something happening that shouldn't if you would risk being noticed? It could just end up encouraging the offender to try to take your phone or worse. Just a thought...

Post 5 of 25

(NT) lol akward! :P

by robstak - 1/28/09 6:11 PM In reply to: The noise can be embarrassing... by hollyhock

Post 6 of 25

I find that the majority of proposed legislation

by minimalist - 2/14/09 10:36 AM In reply to: exactly by mementh

is more about posturing for ones constituency than it is about proposing a well thought out and effective solution that is actually constitutional.

Representatives can be such cynical bottom feeders sometimes.

Post 7 of 25

The National Initative for Democracy

by Nicholas Buenk - 2/14/09 8:03 PM In reply to: I find that the majority of proposed legislation by minimalist

Representatives suck, this idea would give citizens ability to propose laws via petition and get them passes by referendum, creating effectively a fourth branch of government, the people.
http://www.ni4d.us/

Post 8 of 25

Not sure if that's a good idea.

by minimalist - 2/14/09 9:53 PM In reply to: The National Initative for Democracy by Nicholas Buenk

Mob rule and inflamed partisan politics is exactly what the representatives are playing to. Making it more of a numbers game just makes things even worse.

Most of the numbskulls to which representatives are trying to appeal are unaware that the majority does not always rule in our form of government. They do not understand the difference between a pure democracy and a republic and they find the courts to be a nuisance against the "will of the people".

Post 9 of 25

Representatives

by Nicholas Buenk - 2/15/09 8:04 AM In reply to: Not sure if that's a good idea. by minimalist

Do not do anything other than represent themselves. But they would still exist in this system as would the courts. It's still a republic system.

Post 10 of 25

I would have to look at the details.

by minimalist - 2/15/09 10:36 AM In reply to: Representatives by Nicholas Buenk

Referendums could tip the balance too much in the direction of mob rule. Laws by referendum might be OK. But those laws need to always be subject to a larger Constitution that protects the rights of the minority from the tyranny of the majority.

Situations such as those in California where a simple majority vote can change the Constitution by referendum is unacceptable. At that point a Constitution stands for nothing other than the passions of the day.

Post 11 of 25

(NT) What a great example!

by milkky - 2/15/09 10:43 AM In reply to: I would have to look at the details. by minimalist

Post 12 of 25

dumb.similar to not being able to turn off your phone GPS...

by shmody - 1/29/09 4:32 AM In reply to: Legislation that would force your camera phone to click... by robstak

dumb. similar to not being able to turn off your phone GPS...

There are other ways to address predators. also, expecting perfection is a pipe-dream. however, I'm not yet sure what I would say, face to face, with a person who has had a horrific experience as a result of an encounter with a predator...

Best,
Shalin

Post 13 of 25

the problem is the predator not the phone...

by robstak - 1/31/09 1:02 PM In reply to: dumb.similar to not being able to turn off your phone GPS... by shmody

why not outlaw guns and cigarettes fatty food and roller coasters...

:P

Post 14 of 25

(NT) exactly...

by shmody - 2/1/09 7:28 AM In reply to: the problem is the predator not the phone... by robstak

Post 15 of 25

To be consistent,

by milkky - 2/2/09 5:13 AM In reply to: (NT) exactly... by shmody

are you both also against legislation outlawing using cell phones while driving? It's not the device, it's the distracted driver, for which there are already suffucient laws...

Forum legend:
Locked Locked thread
Moderator Moderator
CNET staff CNET staff
Samsung staff Samsung staff
Norton Authorized Support team Norton Authorized Support team
AVG staff AVG staff
Windows Outreach team Windows Outreach team
Dell staff Dell staff
Intel staff Intel staff
Powered by Jive Software